Sign up for weekly updates

CAPSULE REPORT: ARTICLE 19 charts criminal defamation worldwide with launch of mapping tool

(ARTICLE 19/IFEX) - The following is an abridged version of an 11 December 2007 ARTICLE 19 press release:

Defamation Mapping Tool Charts a Chilling Reality Spanning the Globe

ARTICLE 19, Global Campaign for Free Expression, today launches a global mapping tool that reveals the widespread use of criminal defamation and other insult laws around the world and unacceptable numbers of people imprisoned there under.

Howaida Taha, al Jazeera journalist, was sentenced in absentia on 2 May 2007 by al Nozha Felonies Court in Egypt to six months in prison and hard labour for "possessing and giving pictures and recorded material that undermine the image of the country. . ." Her crime: making a documentary on torture in Egypt.

Francisco Vivanco Riofrío, the President of the daily newspaper La Hora is facing up to 2 years imprisonment for publishing an editorial which Ecuador's President Rafael Correa claimed to be defamatory and of "moral damage" to his reputation. His crime: asserting that the President ruled "with turmoil, rocks and sticks", following violence in the street in the midst of a referendum.

Rojda Kizgin, a reporter for pro-Kurdish News Agency Dicle (DICA), currently is being tried under Article 301 (2) of the Turkish penal code for 'degrading the state's military and security forces'. Her crime: reporting in 2005 that soldiers were using grenades for fishing, and damaging the environment.

In Senegal, the newspaper Walf Grand-Place was sentenced to an exorbitant fine of 10 million CFA Francs or US$21,000 while two of its journalists, Faydy Drame and Jean Meissa Diop, reporter and editor-in-chief respectively, were sentenced to 6 months prison with bail. Their crime: reporting that a model of car sold by Matforce, a Hyundai dealership, was defective.

These are the stories of just 4 of the hundreds of journalists, writers, human rights defenders and others that have faced charges for defamation since January 2005, 146 of whom have received custodial sentences. Countless others have been charged or are facing trials, possible imprisonment or large fines under criminal or civil defamation law.

ARTICLE 19's defamation mapping tool reveals, in the sharpest way possible, the unacceptable and widespread use of outdated and destructive laws that through enforced silence and imprisonment, stifle, censor and suppress freedom of expression.

Defamation has long been denounced by human rights defenders and freedom of the press activists as a grave threat to freedom of expression, yet, there has been little comprehensive or cross-comparative information available for global campaigning. ARTICLE 19's defamation mapping tool plugs this gap. It offers a user-friendly web tool that demonstrates the true and global extent of the problem by way of visual maps connected to campaigning and advocacy actions. Interactive, the toolkit allows users to share information about new cases, changes in laws, and campaigning successes, thus building a global movement against abusive defamation.

Dr Agnès Callamard, Executive Director of ARTICLE 19 said "On this day, alike all others, journalists, human rights defenders, political opponents, and other citizens will be forced to mark Human Rights Day in prison merely because they have reported on abuse of power, or corruption, or criticised a public figure. Countless others will refrain from speaking out about issues of concern for fear of a similar fate. Defamation, both civil and criminal, is one of the greatest threats to freedom of expression in the world today. It is a global problem that requires global action".

Of the 168 countries surveyed, 158 have criminal defamation laws. That means that 94% of the world's countries are subjected to laws that human rights defenders the world over have condemned as inappropriate, abusive, and misused.

113 countries have special laws offering special protection to the most powerful and privileged figures in public life. These laws shield public figures from criticisms and investigation by virtue of the power they hold in society ? eating at the very heart of global efforts to promote good governance and combat corruption.

Only 10 countries have eliminated criminal defamation laws and a further 9 have done away with imprisonment as a penalty for defamation. The successful State leaders of this small, fragmented movement for defamation reform can be found in such countries as Ghana, Mexico, Sri Lanka and in a number of Eastern European countries namely Bosnia and Herzegovina, Estonia, Georgia and Ukraine.

Although largely fallen into disuse across Western Europe, the existence of criminal defamation on the statute books provides many other governments in Africa, Asia and the Middle East with the excuse they need not only to refute repeal of defamation laws but also to actively make use of such laws to imprison journalists from periods of a few months to several years. Such cases are often used to make an example of journalists, thereby demarcating a line which few others dare to traverse, creating "no go" topics and rendering politicians and other powerful actors free from the public scrutiny so essential to holding them accountable.

Since January 2005, at least 146 people have been imprisoned for criminal defamation - the worst offenders being Iran (10), Uzbekistan (9), Democratic Republic of Congo (7), China and the Philippines (both 6). Crippling fines and damages awarded in defamation cases add a further restriction to freedom of expression. Many journalists have seen their careers and even their lives crushed by bankrupting fines and damages incurred in defamation cases.

ARTICLE 19's list is not exhaustive. There are gaps caused by impeded communication, censorship and fear of the consequences of disclosure. The actual number of people affected by abusive defamation is therefore likely to be much greater.

For the complete press release, see:

The defamation mapping tool can be accessed at the following general link:

Latest Tweet:

Dr. Abduljalil al-Singace turns 57 – spending yet another birthday behind bars. Dr. al-Singace is a Bahraini human…

Get more stories like this

Sign up for our newsletters and get the most important free expression news delivered to your inbox.