Sign up for weekly updates

Police unlawfully seize files and equipment from human rights organisation

(Human Rights Watch/IFEX) - Moscow, November 10, 2010 - The Ukrainian authorities should immediately return materials and equipment seized from the prominent human rights activist Dmytro Groisman and the organization he leads, and allow the group to resume its lawful human rights activities, Human Rights Watch said today. The authorities should investigate the unlawful interference in the work of the organization, the Vinnytsya Human Rights Group (VHRG), and hold those responsible to account, Human Rights Watch said.

Police searched Groisman's apartment and the group's office in Vinnytsya on October 15, 2010, in connection with an alleged investigation into pornography distribution. The organization, of which Groisman is coordinator, documents human rights abuses, including torture and ill-treatment of people in detention and in psychiatric facilities. The organization also assists refugees and asylum seekers as an implementing partner of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.

"The police used this spurious investigation to seize materials related to human rights work and asylum claims," said Rachel Denber, acting Europe and Central Asia director at Human Rights Watch. "This is harassment, plain and simple."

Groisman was not home during the search. The officers presented a warrant to Groisman's wife, dated September 22, authorizing the search as part of an investigation into the alleged distribution of pornographic materials.

During the eight-hour search, the police seized all DVDs, flash drives, audio, and video materials they found, including family videotapes, as well as a computer and Groisman's wife's personal laptop. The police also confiscated Groisman's bank cards and folders containing information about several of his organization's current refugee cases, on which Groisman was working from home. The folders included refugee interviews, draft court appeals, copies of migration documents, photographs, migrant registration documents, and other confidential materials.

The search warrant made reference to a link to a video posted by Groisman in May 2010 on his private blog. The video, which was also posted on numerous websites including YouTube and at least one major Ukrainian news website, was an exposé on several Russian opposition politicians compromised by sexual activities.

In his blog posting, Groisman expressed his opposition to Russian government officials' use of information about the private lives of oppositional figures to discredit them. The court order authorizing the search noted that a criminal investigation into pornography distribution was opened on September 19, 2010, but did not name any suspects. No one has been charged in connection with the investigation but Groisman has been named as a witness.

After searching Groisman's apartment, the officers insisted on searching the organization's office, located in the same building, although they had no warrant authorizing the search as required by Ukrainian Criminal Procedure Code. The police threatened to break down the office door unless the two staff members present allowed them to enter.

During the six-hour search of the office, police seized the office's three computers and all paper files, which contained a database of all the organization's case files, including confidential information related to refugee claims and torture cases. They also seized confidential files related to two cases pending before the European Court of Human Rights. Since the search, police have regularly called VHRG's staff to the police station for interrogation sessions, during which the police have mainly questioned them about VHRG's work with asylum seekers.

The majority of refugee clients of VHRG are Somalis. In the months prior to the police search of their office, VHRG had been collecting video and audio testimonies of Somali asylum seekers in Vinnytsya being mistreated, including robbed, beaten, and harassed, by police and other law enforcement bodies in Ukraine, and posting those testimonies on the internet.

"Asylum seekers in Ukraine are already tremendously vulnerable under Ukraine's deeply flawed asylum system," Denber said. "The illegal seizure of these confidential files raises serious concerns about possible police retaliation against asylum seekers."

A Human Rights Watch fact-finding mission in June 2010 revealed a poorly functioning and severely corrupt asylum system that leaves asylum seekers especially vulnerable to abuse. Researchers documented many cases in which asylum seekers had experienced ill-treatment, harassment, and extortion by local police.

Groisman wrote to the Vinnytsya Prosecutor's office on October 19, 2010, requesting an immediate investigation into the police's unlawful actions during the search. The office has not responded to his request, even though it was required by law either to open a criminal investigation or provide written justification for not doing so by October 30.

On October 22, 2010, Ukraine's human rights ombudsperson Nina Karpacheva denounced the actions of Ukrainian authorities toward Groisman's organization during a special parliamentary session dedicated to the 60-year anniversary of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Click here to read the entire press release

Latest Tweet:

Iraqi photojournalist Samer Ali Hussain killed in unknown circumstances @GulfCentre4HR

Get more stories like this

Sign up for our newsletters and get the most important free expression news delivered to your inbox.