REGIONS:

SUBSCRIBE:

Sign up for weekly updates

U.S. attorney dismisses majority of charges against journalist Barrett Brown

The U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Texas today (5 March 2014) filed a motion to dismiss 11 charges against Barrett Brown in a criminal prosecution that would have had massive implications for journalism and the right of ordinary people to share links. EFF has written extensively about the case and had planned to file an amicus brief on Monday on behalf of several reporters groups arguing for the dismissal of the indictment.

Brown, an independent journalist, was prosecuted after he shared a link to thousands of pages of stolen documents in an attempt to crowdsource the review of those documents—a common technique for many journalists. The records came from the US government contractor, Stratfor Global Intelligence and documented discussions of assassination, rendition and how to undermine journalists and foreign governments. They also included thousands of stolen credit card numbers. Brown had no involvement in the hack, but was charged nonetheless with identity theft.

In response to the decision by the federal prosecutor's office to drop some, but not all of Brown's charges, EFF issued the following statement:

"We are relieved that federal prosecutors have decided to drop these charges against Barrett Brown. In prosecuting Brown, the government sought to criminalize a routine practice of journalism—linking to external sources—which is a textbook violation of free speech protected by the First Amendment. Although this motion is good news for Brown, the unnecessary and unwarranted prosecution has already done much damage; not only has it harmed Brown, the prosecution—and the threat of prosecution it raised for all journalists—has chilled speech on the Internet. We hope that this dismissal of charges indicates a change in the Department of Justice priorities. If not, we will be ready to step in and defend free speech.”

EFF plans to publish its draft brief and deeper analysis later this week.

ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
What other IFEX members are saying
  • CPJ welcomes dismissal of charges against Barrett Brown

    "The U.S. Department of Justice never should have brought these charges against Barrett Brown, and their dismissal is long overdue," said Geoffrey King, CPJ's Internet Advocacy Coordinator. "Journalists routinely link to information that substantiates their reporting, which may involve sensitive or even stolen documents. The mere filing of these charges undermines U.S. efforts to preserve the interconnected nature of the Web."

Latest Tweet:

Writing on the Wall: Disappeared Booksellers and Freedom of Expression in #HongKong - @PENamerican @IntPublishers https://t.co/V99S0dhNbg